Your puppy's first nights
For the first nights, your puppy sleeps in your room, door closed, in his own bed, not in yours. If he cries, it isn't a tantrum: he has just left his mother and his littermates. Keeping him close reassures him, and it lets you hear when he needs to go out for a wee.
He has just left his mother and his littermates
Overnight, your puppy left his mother, his littermates and the place he was born in, and landed in a house he doesn't know yet. When he cries at night, it isn't a tantrum, and it has nothing to do with “dominance” either. A landmark study on wild wolves showed, as far back as 1999, that a pack isn't a hierarchy of rivals but a family: parents guiding their young, with no fight for power. And in dogs, a 2009 study reaches the same conclusion: there is no evidence that a dog has a “dominant” temperament, nor that his reactions can be explained by a wish to get the upper hand over you.
Sleeping in your room, your puppy is less stressed, and he cries less at night. Feeling you nearby soothes him: a 1998 study showed that a dog, much like a young child with his parents, seeks contact with his owner after a separation.
What you need for the night
Before you turn the light off, get these few things ready, nothing more.
0 / 4The bedtime routine
In the evening, take him out and let his excitement settle: no more play, just calm.
The evening wee and poo break
Take him out around 8.30pm if he eats at 8pm, so he ends the evening with an empty bladder and an empty stomach.
A quiet end to the evening, close to you
Between dinner and your bedtime, he stays with you in the room, settled in his bed or at your feet. No more play that winds him up: let his energy come down gently.
One last wee just before you go to bed
Take him out one final time as you head off to sleep. For the very first nights, push your bedtime back a little, to around midnight, to shorten the stretch he'll spend without a break. Go back to your usual time after 3 or 4 nights, or as soon as he lasts through without an accident.
Bed, door closed, lights out
Guide him to his bed and go to sleep. If he doesn't settle straight away, don't stand there beside him: just stay in the room, your presence is enough. With the door closed, he can't go and wee somewhere else, and you can hear if he gets restless. He sleeps in his own bed, not in yours.
Nights that get longer
Don't rush anything: his nights get longer at the pace of his bladder, not to a fixed calendar.
Step 1 / 3Avoid accidents while he learns that the night is for sleeping.
- Set an alarm every 2 hours for the wee break
- Take him out calmly, with no play and no excitement, then bring him straight back to his bed
- If you get up in the night yourself, take him out too: the noise will wake him, and a woken puppy often needs a wee
Move on when: After 2 or 3 nights with no accident on the 2-hour alarm, you can start spacing the breaks out.
Longer and longer nights, tuned to his growing bladder.
- Wait for 2 or 3 nights with no accident at one step before adding 30 minutes to 1 hour: 2 hrs, then 3 hrs, then 4 hrs
- If he wees at one of the wake-ups, you've gone too fast: go back to the previous step the following night, then try again
- Watch him: when he fidgets in his bed or gets up, he's asking to go out
Move on when: He lasts 5 to 6 hours in a row without needing to go out, which doesn't mean he is house-trained during the day.
A dog who chooses where to sleep himself, because he feels at home anywhere in the house.
- Keep him in the bedroom as long as he can't be left alone without panicking or destroying things
- Once he can be left alone without anxiety, which is learned through gradual absences during the day, leave the bedroom door open at night
- Let him choose: he'll end up sleeping outside the bedroom of his own accord
Telling a wee cry from a distress cry
At night, two cries sound alike but aren't handled the same way. The wee cry: he gets up, turns around in his bed, scratches, and the sound comes back in short, urgent bursts. There, take him out, he wees, and back to bed, without another word. The distress cry: he stays lying down and whines on a steady note, without fidgeting. There, you can talk to him softly from your bed, or put your hand near his bed: often, your voice and your presence are enough. If he doesn't settle after two or three minutes, sit back down beside him for a moment, as you did at bedtime, then go back to bed. When in doubt, take him out anyway: a boring wee break, with no play and no cuddles, reinforces nothing, whereas a held-in wee ends in an accident. What you never do is take him out of his bed to play, or lift him into your bed the moment he whimpers: that, he can learn from the very first time.
In a flat, the night-time trip out takes longer: you have to go down the stairs or wait for the lift, then get through the front door of the building. Keep your keys, a lead and easy shoes by the bed so you can leave quickly. And put a waterproof mat or an absorbent pad near the door: if he can't hold on while you make your way down, an accident on the mat is better than a puppy in distress. You aren't encouraging him to use it, you're just limiting the damage while he learns.
- Mech — Alpha status, dominance, and division of labor in wolf packs (the pack is a family, not a hierarchy) (1999)
- Topál, Miklósi, Csányi & Dóka — Attachment behavior in dogs: an adaptation of Ainsworth's Strange Situation test (1998)
- Bradshaw, Blackwell & Casey — Dominance in domestic dogs: useful construct or bad habit? (2009)
Going further
Frequently asked questions
Why is my dog crying?
A whimper is communication: he is signalling a need (going out, hunger, boredom, fear of being alone) or a discomfort. Look at the context instead of silencing the noise, and reward him when he is calm rather than telling him off when he cries. If the crying is sudden, or happens when he moves or when you touch him, think of pain first and call your vet.
Why is my dog crying at night?
In a puppy, it is almost always separation: he has just left his mother and his littermates and finds himself alone. The answer isn't to shut him away but to have him sleep in your room, door closed. His cries are also there to tell you he needs to go out for a wee.
Should you let a puppy cry at night?
No. He often ends up going quiet within 2 to 3 nights, but because he is giving up, not because he feels better, and that distress can feed his anxiety. Keeping him close reassures him and actually speeds up how quickly he learns to sleep through.
I feel guilty about leaving my dog alone.
If his needs are met (walk, play, nap before you leave), he experiences the absence as a moment of rest, not as abandonment. Teach him to be alone through small, positive absences: calm departures and calm returns, and a chew or activity toy kept just for those moments. You haven't done anything wrong, you are teaching him to be happy on his own.
How long can a dog hold on at night?
Many puppies last 5 to 6 hours in a row at night, because their system slows down during sleep, but it varies a lot from one puppy to another and it doesn't mean he is house-trained during the day. A simple rule of thumb: he lasts roughly his age in months plus one hour, so about 3 hours at 2 months and 5 hours at 4 months. At the start, take him out every 2 hours, then space it out gradually (3 hrs, then 4 hrs) as his bladder matures. Most puppies still need a night-time break until they are 4 or 5 months old, and reliable bladder control often settles in between 4 and 6 months.
Where should a puppy sleep on the first night?
In your room, in his own bed, door closed, but not in your bed. He has just left everything behind: your presence reassures him, and it lets you hear when he needs to go out. And no, he won't “want to stay there for life”: that's a myth, and it has nothing to do with his ability to sleep alone later on.
Updated on Sources
Read nextNext in this pathFeeding your puppy wellReadLoading your progress…