When my dog barks too much
A dog who barks a lot isn't being difficult: he's communicating, and it's nearly always a sign of something else, boredom, frustration, a bid for attention, an alert or time alone he struggles with. Find the cause, fill the need that's missing, reward the quiet. Never an anti-bark collar.
Look for the cause
Barking is part of what a dog normally does: he warns, he calls his group, he expresses an emotion. Shutting that down by force means taking away his warning signal, and a dog who is stopped from “speaking” sometimes gives less warning before he reacts. So the aim isn't silence at any price, it's finding the cause behind the noise.
Barking and growling are the words your dog uses to warn you before going any further. Punishing them, or trying to silence them, is linked to more fear and more aggression in dogs: better to leave the signal intact and tackle what sets it off.
What makes your dog bark
Alert and territory
- Someone walks past your home, the doorbell rings, there's a noise outside: your dog flags it up and “calls” his group.
- A short, targeted bark is normal; the real problem is when he never comes back down.
- In the garden or at the window, a passer-by who comes back again and again, the postman or the neighbours, keeps the barking going all by itself.
Demanding and frustration
- He barks for his bowl, a game or a walk, and he wants them right now.
- Like a child demanding something: if barking “works”, he does it again.
- Answering him, even with a “be quiet”, teaches him that it works.
Boredom and too little outlet
- He doesn't get out enough, isn't stimulated enough, doesn't have enough to chew on: the surplus energy comes out through his voice.
- The mind often tires faster than the body.
- The first move is to enrich his day: sniffing, chewing, search games.
Being alone and anxiety
- He barks or howls mainly when he's alone, sometimes for hours.
- At that point it's no longer a barking problem, it's time alone he can't cope with.
- That's a subject in its own right: it's worked on with a proper method, little by little, never with punishment, and professional support often helps.
Mournful howling
- He answers a siren, other dogs, or he calls out when he's alone.
- Howling is also his way of saying “I'm on my own, where are you?”: if that's the case, the cause is the same time-alone problem as just above.
- Depending on the cause, you get your dog used to the noise little by little, or, for time alone, you follow what's described just above.
Spot it, fill the gap, praise him
You start from the cause, you enrich his days, then you teach him that calm pays.
Spot the trigger
Note the time, the situation and what sets the barking off. When it happens while you're out, a small camera filming the room, or a neighbour telling you what they hear and when, gives you the missing context. It's that context that will tell you what to do, not a precise figure.
Fill the needs first
To start today: a proper walk where he's allowed to sniff at his own pace, something to chew on when you get home, and his evening bowl hidden around the house so he has to track it down by scent. A dog whose mind is tired barks a great deal less. The guide on exercising and occupying him, further down, goes further.
Cut short a bark that's already started
At the window, close the curtain or the shutter: with nothing to watch going past, there's no more reason to bark. Then call him over in a cheerful voice and reward the simple fact that he comes, that pulls him out of the scene. Move him away from the window and get him busy with something else. You're helping him let go, you're not punishing him.
Get in ahead of him at the window and in the garden
Learn the signs just before the barking: the ears pricking up, the body straightening, the trot towards the window. At that moment, offer him a game kept only for this, a tug rope for instance, stored within reach near the window. If he drops the game to go and bark, the game stops and you put the rope away.
With demanding barking, don't reward the noise
He's barking for his bowl or a game? Not a look, not a word: carry on with what you were doing. Wait for a few seconds of quiet, and only then praise him and give him what he was waiting for. Rewarding after a gap breaks the link between the barking and the reward; giving in while he barks reinforces it. If he steps it up, scratches or insists, whatever you do don't give in at the peak: take what he wants right out of sight for a moment and pick it up again once he's calm.
Reward calm with a marker word
Every time the quiet comes back on its own, mark it with a calm “yes”, then reward straight away. From now on it's the quiet that pays, not the barking.
Handle it yourself, or get help?
You can go it alone
- Alert, demanding or boredom barking in a balanced dog.
- The dog comes back down once the trigger has passed.
- You can enrich his days and stay consistent day to day.
Get some support
- Panicked barking or howling the moment you leave: that's separation anxiety.
- Barking loaded with fear, or paired with aggression.
- An alert that never comes back down, even once the trigger has gone, despite well-filled days.
- A sudden, unexplained change: start with a visit to the vet to rule out a medical cause.
- Herron, Shofer & Reisner — Survey of the use and outcome of confrontational and non-confrontational training methods in client-owned dogs (2009)
- Ziv — The effects of using aversive training methods in dogs: A review (2017)
- China, Mills & Cooper — Efficacy of dog training with and without remote electronic collars vs. reward-based training (2020)
- AVSAB — Position Statement on Humane Dog Training (2021)
Going further
Frequently asked questions
How do you stop a dog from barking?
You treat what sets the barking off: it's a language, not a noise to be forcibly silenced. Identify the cause, fill your dog's needs, give him physical and mental exercise, then reward the calm with a marker word. Never an anti-bark collar: it removes the signal without fixing anything.
How do you quieten a barking dog?
In the moment, stay calm: shouting means barking back at him. Cut off whatever is winding him up if you can, close the curtain, call him over, reward him when he comes, then wait for a real second of quiet so you can mark it with a “yes”. But the lasting fix is understanding why he barks, not just turning the sound off.
Why does my dog bark all the time?
Constant barking is nearly always a symptom: boredom, too little outlet, frustration or difficulty being left alone. Look for the cause, not a number of minutes not to exceed. If it appeared suddenly in a usually quiet dog, have him seen by the vet to rule out pain.
Why does my dog bark at night?
Often it's a noise that alerts him, the discomfort of being alone, or quite simply a puppy still settling in. In an older dog who barks or paces at night, think of cognitive decline too and mention it to your vet. Treat the cause, don't punish him.
Anti-bark collars: a good idea?
No. It's a shock or spray device that punishes your dog for expressing himself, through pain or discomfort: it removes the symptom, never the cause, and it manufactures fear, sometimes a dog who no longer warns before reacting. Better to look for why he barks and treat that.
How do I teach my dog to hush?
Start by rewarding the quiet: wait a few seconds without barking, mark them with a “yes” and reward. Once he goes quiet easily, slip in the word “hush” in a calm voice just before that quiet, so he learns to respond to it. A shouted “hush” doesn't work: to his ears it sounds like one more bark, coming from you.
Updated on Sources
Read nextNext in this pathDog jumping up on peopleReadLoading your progress…