Walking on a lead without pulling
Walking attached to a lead is nothing like natural for your dog: he moves faster than you, and the more you hold him back, the harder he pulls. Pick one side and stick to it, keep the lead loose in a “U” shape, and turn around without a word as soon as he gets ahead of you. Reward him against your leg when he comes back: that spot is the one he learns to hold.
Why your dog pulls
For a dog, moving forward on a lead is nothing like natural: he walks faster than you, he wants to sniff, greet, explore, and the lead stops him. Every time he pulls and still gets to move forward, it works, so he does it again. And when you hold him back, he pushes the other way, just as you would if someone pushed you: trainers call this the opposition reflex. The result: the more you pull, the more he pulls. Pulling is neither a whim nor disobedience, it is a logical reaction to a constraint he does not yet understand.
Pulling to get somewhere, and pulling because another dog or a passer-by winds him up, are two different subjects. The first one is lead walking: that is this guide. The second one touches his emotions, and is worked on separately.
The right conditions before you start
Good conditions beat ten clever tricks: a settled dog learns, a dog under pressure does not. This method works at any age, from puppy to adult dog.
0 / 4The turnaround method
It is the movement of your leg that decides the direction: a loose lead always pays.
Pick a side and keep it
Decide that he always walks on the same side, to the left or to the right of your leg, whichever you like: that steady landmark is what he needs to line himself up with you. If he has already got used to one side, you can keep it or change it, what matters is sticking to it afterwards. Hold the lead in the hand on that side, and keep the other hand free for treats.
Keep the lead loose, in a “U”
Hold the lead at hip height, with enough slack for it to hang in a “U” between your hand and his collar or harness, never pulled straight and tight: that is where he is most comfortable, with no tension on his neck.
The moment he gets past your leg, turn around, without a word
As soon as his shoulder is about 30 cm past your knee, pivot 180 degrees on the spot and walk calmly back the other way, at the same pace, without the slightest jerk on the lead: he is the one who creates the tension by getting ahead of you, never you pulling on it. Keep walking like that for a few steps, until he comes back to you on his own. If he plants himself and refuses to move, which often happens with a dog who pulls hard, whatever you do, do not pull on the lead: encourage him with your voice, get him to follow you by moving off gently, and if that is not enough, go back to an easier exercise, with less distance or less distraction.
Reward him when he comes back level with you
Say your marker word (“yes!”) exactly when his shoulder comes back to the same landmark as on the way out, level with your knee, then give the treat right there, against your thigh, not in a hand held out in front of him: because you judge the start and the return at the same spot, he clearly learns the place to hold, not just to come back towards you.
Add temptations bit by bit
For example someone he loves standing 50 m away, or a toy placed in front of him: as long as he walks with a loose lead, move towards the reward; if he gets past your leg, turn around.
The marker word, a short word such as “yes!”, is said at the precise moment his shoulder is level with you: that word tells him exactly which position you are rewarding, without you needing to have the treat already in hand.
The kit that helps, and the kit to avoid
Kit will not train your dog for you, but the right tool makes the work possible and the wrong one sabotages it.
What helps him walk on a loose lead
Leave these in the cupboard
A permanently tight lead presses on the neck and the windpipe; a 2006 study showed that pulling on a collar raises the pressure inside the eyes, which does not happen with a harness. Aiming for the loose “U” protects his neck too.
The most common sticking points
He freezes and refuses to move
- The lead is often too short: switch to a long line to give him back space and time.
- Do not insist, do not carry him, do not fuss over him: move on calmly and wait for him to decide to set off again.
- Reward the restart as soon as he gets going.
He anticipates your turnarounds and turns it into a game
- Stop the token little turnarounds: really go back several metres, not just a single step.
- Vary left, right, backwards: he should no longer be able to guess which one you will pick.
He rushes towards another dog
- This is no longer a lead-walking matter, it is an emotion rising: increase the distance from the other dog before it spills over.
- Reward him for staying calm as long as he does not react, never for wanting to get to the other dog.
He is a small dog and he barely pulls
- If he is not choking himself and it bothers nobody, it is not a problem to fix urgently.
- The same method works for him too, in a quieter version, scaled to his size.
- AVSAB — Position Statement on Humane Dog Training (2021)
- Ziv G. — The effects of using aversive training methods in dogs: a review (2017)
- Pauli et al. — Effects of the application of neck pressure by a collar or harness on intraocular pressure in dogs (2006)
- Duranton & Horowitz — Let me sniff! Nosework induces positive judgement bias in pet dogs (2019)
- Morrill et al. — Ancestry-inclusive dog genomics challenges popular breed stereotypes (Science) (2022)
Going further
Frequently asked questions
Why does my dog pull on the lead?
Because walking on a lead is not natural for him: he moves faster than you and wants to sniff or reach whatever draws him, and if pulling gets him there, he does it again. When you hold him back, his opposition reflex pushes him to pull even harder. It is not disobedience, just a logical reaction, and it can be put right without any force at all.
How do you teach a dog to walk on a lead?
Pick one side and stick to it, keep the lead nicely loose in a “U”, and turn around without a word as soon as he gets past your leg: he is the one creating the tension, not you pulling. Say “yes!” and reward him against your leg the moment he comes back level with you. Work in short sessions, week after week: it works better than one long forced walk.
How do you stop a dog pulling on the lead?
Never pull the other way: through the opposition reflex, it encourages him to push harder. The silent turnaround teaches him that pulling does not get him anywhere, and that a loose lead always pays. Let him burn off energy before the outing, and let him off the lead regularly: a dog who gets real freedom pulls far less.
How do you walk a dog who pulls while he is still learning?
For everyday outings, a well-fitted front-clip harness reduces the pull and protects his neck while the method beds in. Keep time off the lead on a long line so he can sniff, and save the turnarounds for short training sessions. Never a choke or an electric collar.
Which harness or collar for a dog who pulls?
Go for a well-adjusted front-clip harness for a dog who already pulls hard, or a light flat collar with a soft lead to start out with precision. Rule out choke, prong and electric collars: they work through pain, and they are no more effective than rewards. As for the head collar, it constrains the head without teaching him to walk on a loose lead.
How long does it take for a dog to stop pulling?
There is no fixed timescale: it depends on his history and above all on how consistent you are. It is not the number of days that counts, it is the consistency: even 10 quality metres on every outing beat one long messy walk. And do not read too much into breed: a large 2022 genetic study showed it explains only about 9% of the behavioural differences between one dog and another.
Updated on Sources
Read nextNext in this pathTeaching your dog to come back when calledReadLoading your progress…